Tradable instruments to fight climate change: A disappointing outcome

Opinion

Philippe Quirion

Published Online: Mar 04 2021

DOI: 10.1002/wcc.705

Full article on Wiley Online Library: HTML PDF

Can't access this content? Tell your librarian.

Abstract Various tradable instruments have been implemented for climate change mitigation: emission trading systems, tradable energy‐efficiency obligations, and tradable renewable energy quotas. Their track record has been disappointing so far; almost every emission trading has suffered from over‐allocation which has undermined its effectiveness; tradable energy‐efficiency obligations seem to have mostly co‐financed investments that would have taken place anyway; tradable renewable energy quotas suffer from several shortcomings compared to alternative support systems, that is, feed‐in tariffs and premiums. I discuss the reasons for these failures (especially too superficial a reading by policy makers of the work of researchers) and ways to improve the situation (including encouraging systematic syntheses of academic work). This article is categorized under: Climate Economics > Economics of Mitigation

References

Ademe (2020). Evaluation du dispositif des certificats d`économie d`énergie – Rapport synthétique. Ademe
Alagappan,, L., Orans,, R., & Woo,, C. K. (2011). What drives renewable energy development? Energy Policy, 39(9), 5099–5104.
Aldrich,, E. L., & Koerner,, C. L. (2018). White certificate trading: A dying concept or just making its debut? Part II: Challenges to trading white certificates. The Electricity Journal, 31(4), 41–47.
Andersson,, J. J. (2019). Carbon taxes and CO2 emissions: Sweden as a case study. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 11(4), 1–30.
Bailey,, I. (2010). The EU emissions trading scheme. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change, 1(1), 144–153.
Borenstein,, S., Bushnell,, J., Wolak,, F. A., & Zaragoza‐Watkins,, M. (2019). Expecting the unexpected: Emissions uncertainty and environmental market design. American Economic Review, 109(11), 3953–3977.
Branger,, F., Lecuyer,, O., & Quirion,, P. (2015). The European Union emissions trading scheme: Should we throw the flagship out with the bathwater? Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change, 6(1), 9–16.
Buchner,, B., & Ellerman,, E. D. (2006). Over‐allocation or abatement? A preliminary analysis of the EU ETS based on the 2005–06 emissions data. Environmental and Resource Economics, 2008, 41(2), 267–287.
Burtraw,, D., & Keyes,, A. (2018). Recognizing gravity as a strong force in atmosphere emissions markets. Agricultural and Resource Economics Review, 47(2), 201–219.
Carley,, S., Baldwin,, E., MacLean,, L. M., & Brass,, J. N. (2017). Global expansion of renewable energy generation: An analysis of policy instruments. Environmental and Resource Economics, 68(2), 397–440.
Crocker,, T. D. (1966). The structuring of atmospheric pollution control systems. In: Wolozin H (ed.), The Economics of Air Pollution, A Symposium, pp. 61–86.
Dales,, J. H. (1968). Land, water, and ownership. The Canadian Journal of Economics/Revue canadienne d`Economique, 1(4), 791–804.
Dong,, C. G. (2012). Feed‐in tariff vs. renewable portfolio standard: An empirical test of their relative effectiveness in promoting wind capacity development. Energy Policy, 42, 476–485.
Fawcett,, T., Rosenow,, J., & Bertoldi,, P. (2019). Energy efficiency obligation schemes: Their future in the EU. Energy Efficiency, 12(1), 57–71.
Flachsland,, C., Pahle,, M., Burtraw,, D., Edenhofer,, O., Elkerbout,, M., Fischer,, C., … Zetterberg,, L. (2020). How to avoid history repeating itself: The case for an EU emissions trading system (EU ETS) price floor revisited. Climate Policy, 20(1), 133–142.
Fuss,, S., Flachsland,, C., Koch,, N., Kornek,, U., Knopf,, B., & Edenhofer,, O. (2018). A framework for assessing the performance of cap‐and‐trade systems: Insights from the European Union emissions trading system. Review of Environmental Economics and Policy, 12(2), 220–241.
García‐Álvarez,, M. T., Cabeza‐García,, L., & Soares,, I. (2017). Analysis of the promotion of onshore wind energy in the EU: Feed‐in tariff or renewable portfolio standard? Renewable Energy, 111, 256–264.
Giraudet,, L. G., Bodineau,, L., & Finon,, D. (2012). The costs and benefits of white certificates schemes. Energy Efficiency, 5(2), 179–199.
Giraudet,, L.‐G., Bourgeois,, C., & Quirion,, P. (2020). Efficacité économique et effets distributifs de long‐terme des politiques de rénovation énergétique des logements. Economie et Prévision, 217(2020/1), 43–63.
Giraudet,, L.‐G., Bourgeois,, C., Quirion,, P. & Glotin,, D. (2018). Evaluation prospective des politiques de réduction de la demande d`énergie pour le chauffage résidentiel. Rapport pour Ademe, MTES et ATEE, CIRED
Giraudet,, L. G., Glachant,, M., & Nicolaï,, J. P. (2020). Selling and saving energy: Energy efficiency obligations in liberalized energy markets. The Energy Journal, 41(Special Issue), 191–213.
Grashof,, K. (2019). Are auctions likely to deter community wind projects? And would this be problematic? Energy Policy, 125, 20–32.
Laing,, T., Sato,, M., Grubb,, M., & Comberti,, C. (2014). The effects and side‐effects of the EU emissions trading scheme. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change, 5(4), 509–519.
Lepoittevin,, D. (2017). Analyse des résidences principales et de leurs occupants, au travers de l`étiquette énergie conventionnelle du diagnostic de performance énergétique (DPE). Thema Analyse, Service de l`observation et des statistiques, ministère de l`écologie, mars.
Lilliestam,, J., Patt,, A., & Bersalli,, G. (2021). The effect of carbon pricing on technological change for full energy decarbonization: A review of empirical ex‐post evidence. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change, 12(1), e681.
Misiolek,, W. S., & Elder,, H. W. (1989). Exclusionary manipulation of markets for pollution rights. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 16(2), 156–166.
Moledina,, A. A., Coggins,, J. S., Polasky,, S., & Costello,, C. (2003). Dynamic environmental policy with strategic firms: Prices versus quantities. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 45(2), 356–376.
Montgomery,, W. D. (1972). Markets in licenses and efficient pollution control programs. Journal of Economic Theory, 5(3), 395–418.
Narassimhan,, E., Gallagher,, K. S., Koester,, S., & Alejo,, J. R. (2018). Carbon pricing in practice: A review of existing emissions trading systems. Climate Policy, 18(8), 967–991.
Newell,, R. G., & Pizer,, W. A. (2008). Indexed regulation. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 56(3), 221–233.
Nicolini,, M., & Tavoni,, M. (2017). Are renewable energy subsidies effective? Evidence from Europe. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 74, 412–423.
OECD, 2020, Policy instruments for the environment (PINE) database. Retrieved from http://oe.cd/pine.
Park,, H., & Lee,, M. (2020). Factors determining firms` trading decision in the Korea ETS market. Environmental Economics and Policy Studies, 1–24. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10018-020-00281-8.
Perino,, G. (2018). New EU ETS phase 4 rules temporarily puncture waterbed. Nature Climate Change, 8(4), 262–264.
Pizer,, W. A. (1999). The optimal choice of climate change policy in the presence of uncertainty. Resource and Energy Economics, 21(3–4), 255–287.
Postic,, S., & Fettet,, M. (2020). Global carbon account in 2020. I4CE, Paris. Retrieved from https://www.i4ce.org/download/global-carbon-account-in-2020/
Quirion,, P. (2005). Does uncertainty justify intensity emission caps? Resource and Energy Economics, 27(4), 343–353.
Quirion,, P. (2015). Quels soutiens aux énergies renouvelables électriques? Revue française d`économie, 30(4), 105–140.
Reklev,, S. (2016). Allowance surplus in China`s pilot markets to grow as slowdown hits power, manufacturing sectors. Carbon Pulse, January 19. Retrieved from http://carbon-pulse.com/14356/
REN21 2017. Renewables. Global status report. Paris: REN21 Secretariat.
Rosenow,, J., & Bayer,, E. (2017). Costs and benefits of energy efficiency obligations: A review of European programmes. Energy Policy, 107, 53–62.
Smessaert,, J., Missemer,, A., & Levrel,, H. (2020). The commodification of nature, a review in social sciences. Ecological Economics, 172, 106624.
Smith,, S., & Swierzbinski,, J. (2007). Assessing the performance of the UKemissions trading scheme. Environmental and Resource Economics, 37(1), 131–158.
UK. Provisional UK greenhouse gas emissions national statistics 2018. Retrieved from https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/provisional-uk-greenhouse-gas-emissions-national-statistics
Weitzman,, M. L. (1974). Prices vs. quantities. The Review of Economic Studies, 41(4), 477–491.

Society Partners

	Royal Geographical Society (with IBG)
	Royal Meteorological Society

Access to this WIREs title is by subscription only.

Recommend to Your
Librarian Now!

Tradable instruments to fight climate change: A disappointing outcome

Browse by Topic

Society Partners

Access to this WIREs title is by subscription only.

The latest WIREs articles in your inbox