How to cite this WIREs title:
WIREs Energy Environ.

Impact Factor: 2.922

An assessment of price convergence between natural gas and solar photovoltaic in the U.S. electricity market

Advanced Review

Joseph Nyangon, John Byrne, Job Taminiau

Published Online: Dec 15 2016

DOI: 10.1002/wene.238

Full article on Wiley Online Library: HTML PDF

Can't access this content? Tell your librarian.

The U.S. shale boom has exerted downward pressure on natural gas prices nationally, widened oil‐to‐gas price spreads, and accelerated coal‐to‐gas fuel substitution. One concern is the impact of the rising production of shale gas on further development of a domestic solar photovoltaic (PV) market. Specifically, will lower natural gas prices slow or even reverse the current rapid growth in the solar market? Using the Phillips–Sul convergence test, this paper investigates whether the levelized cost of energy (LCOE) of solar PV and natural gas electricity generation in the United States have converged. Using weekly Henry Hub‐linked natural gas spot prices and utility PV system prices from 2010 to 2015, empirical tests for convergence are applied to examine the extent of spot market integration and the speed with which market forces move the two energy prices toward equilibrium. The paper also assesses the link between the MAC Solar Energy Index (SUNIDX) and the S&P GSCI natural gas index spot prices for evidence of market integration during 2007–2015. We conclude that PV and natural gas prices are not converging, and the two markets are not integrated nationally, but some level of integration could exist at regional and state levels that will need to be tested in future research. We also conclude that complementary use of the technologies is likely; while price convergence is not likely to occur soon, distinctive complementary benefits of each resource compared to each other (e.g., fast‐start capabilities for gas and low price volatility for PV) will offer opportunities that expand market demand for both. WIREs Energy Environ 2017, 6:e238. doi: 10.1002/wene.238 This article is categorized under: Photovoltaics > Economics and Policy Energy Systems Economics > Systems and Infrastructure

Development of the U.S. PV market categorized by residential, nonresidential, and utility‐scale PV installations. Notes: The total U.S. PV capacity additions are based on GTM Research and SEIA (2010–2015), IREC's data collection, and LBNL's Tracking the Sun database. GTM, Greentech Media; PV, photovoltaic; SEIA, Solar Energy Industries Association.

[ Normal View | Magnified View ]

Price volatility in the PV and natural gas markets. PV, photovoltaic.

[ Normal View | Magnified View ]

Natural gas and SUNIDX indices log spot prices.

[ Normal View | Magnified View ]

Relative transition paths (club convergence).

[ Normal View | Magnified View ]

Sensitivity analysis of PV system model parameters. Sensitivity analysis was conducted by adjusting the input variables up and down +/−10%.

[ Normal View | Magnified View ]

LCOEs of CHP and PV systems. CHP, Combined Heat and Power System; LCOE, levelized cost of energy; PV, photovoltaic.

[ Normal View | Magnified View ]

Levelized cost of energy of natural gas‐fired CHP and utility‐scale PV generation systems. CHP, Combined Heat and Power System; PV, photovoltaic.

[ Normal View | Magnified View ]

Performance of solar and natural gas indices from 2008 to 2015.

[ Normal View | Magnified View ]

Historical changes in daily natural gas spread 2008–2015. Notes: Prices are based on delivery at the Henry Hub in Louisiana. Official daily closing prices at 2:30 p.m. are obtained from the trading floor of the NYMEX for a specific delivery month. The NGPL composite price is derived from daily Bloomberg spot price data for natural gas liquids at Mont Belvieu, Texas, weighted by gas processing plant production volumes of each product as reported on Form EIA‐816, ‘Monthly Natural Gas Liquids Report.’ The SONAT Index is a monthly cash‐settled Exchange Futures Contract based on the mathematical result of subtracting the monthly price published by Inside FERC, as defined in Reference Price B (Natural Gas‐Southern Natural (Louisiana)‐Inside FERC), from the average of the daily prices published by Gas Daily, as defined in Reference Price A (Natural Gas‐Louisiana (Southern Natural)‐Gas Daily). Price quotation convention is one hundredth of a cent ($0.0001) per MMBtu. NGPL, natural gas liquids; NYMEX, New York Mercantile Exchange.

[ Normal View | Magnified View ]

Growth in shale production gas.

[ Normal View | Magnified View ]

Major gas‐producing states. Notes: Data for 2014 are estimated. Monthly preliminary (from January 2014 to present) state‐level data for the production series, except marketed production, are not available until after the final annual reports for these series are collected and processed. From 2007 onward, gross production from coalbed methane and shale data are obtained from PointLogic Energy. Coalbed methane refers to methane generated during coal formation and is contained in the coal microstructure. Typical recovery entails pumping water out of the coal to allow the gas to escape. Methane is the principal component of natural gas. Coalbed methane can be added to natural gas pipelines without any special treatment.

[ Normal View | Magnified View ]

The utility PV project pipeline indicates strong future growth in the sector. PV, photovoltaic.

[ Normal View | Magnified View ]

References

Byrne, J, Taminiau, J, Kim, KN, Seo, J, Lee, J. A solar city strategy applied to six municipalities: Integrating market, finance, and policy factors for infrastructure‐scale photovoltaic development in Amsterdam, London, Munich, New York, Seoul, and Tokyo. WIREs Energy Environ 2016, 5:69–88. doi:10.1002/wene.182.
U.S. Energy Information Administration. What are greenhouse gases and how much are emitted by the United States. Department of Energy, 2014a. Available at: http://www.eia.gov/energy_in_brief/article/greenhouse_gas.cfm. (Accessed June 24, 2016).
U.S. Energy Information Administration. Annual Energy Outlook 2014, 2014d. Available at: http://www.eia.gov/forecasts/aeo/pdf/0383(2014).pdf. (Accessed July 25, 2016).
Lane, JL, Smart, S, Schmeda‐Lopez, D, Hoegh‐Guldberg, O, Garnett, A, Greig, C, McFarland, E. Understanding constraints to the transformation rate of global energy infrastructure. WIREs Energy Environ 2016, 5:33–48. doi:10.1002/wene.177.
Lu, X, Salovaara, J, McElroy, MB. Implications of the recent reductions in natural gas prices for emissions of CO₂ from the US power sector. Environ Sci Technol 2012, 46:3014–3021.
U.S. Department of Energy (DOE). Quadrennial Energy Review (QER) report: energy transmission, storage, and distribution infrastructure, April, 2015. Available at: http://energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2015/04/f22/QER‐ALL%20FINAL_0.pdf. (Accessed June 30, 2015).
U.S. Energy Information Administration. Annual Energy Outlook 2014, 2014b. Available at: http://www.eia.gov/forecasts/aeo/pdf/0383(2014).pdf. (Accessed June 25, 2016).
U.S. Energy Information Administration. Monthly energy review June 2016. Table 7.3b consumption of combustible fuels for electricity generation: electric power sector (Subset of Table 7.3a), 2016. Available at: http://www.eia.gov/forecasts/aeo/pdf/0383(2014).pdf. (Accessed June 20, 2016).
Asche, F, Oglend, A, Osmundsen, P. Gas versus oil prices. The impact of shale gas. Energy Policy 2012, 47:112–124.
Weiss, J, Bishop, H, Fox‐Penner, P, Shavel, I. Partnering Natural Gas and Renewable Energy in ERCOT. Cambridge, MA: The Brattle Group, 2013.
Oglend, A, Lindback, M, Osmundsen, P. Shale gas boom affecting the relationship between LPG and oil prices. Energy J 2016, 37:265–286.
Erdős, P. Have oil and gas prices got separated? Energy Policy 2012, 49:707–718.
Neumann, A, Siliverstovs, B, von Hirschhausen, C. Convergence of European spot market prices for natural gas? A real‐time analysis of market integration using the Kalman filter. Appl Econ Lett 2006, 13:727–732.
Neumann, A. Linking natural gas markets‐is LNG doing its job? Energy J 2009, 30(Special Issue):187–200.
Stock, JH, Watson, MW. Introduction to Econometrics. Pearson Publishing, 3rd ed., 2011, 649.
Barret, CB. Measuring integration and efficiency in international agricultural markets. Rev Agric Econ 2001, 23:19–32.
Giulietti, M, Iregui, AM, Otero, J. A pair‐wise analysis of the law of one price: evidence from the crude oil market. Econ Lett 2015, 129:39–41.
Stigler, GJ, Sherwin, RA. The extent of the market. J Law Econ 1985, 28:555–585.
Johansen, S. Statistical analysis of cointegration vectors. J Econ Dyn Control 1988, 12:231–254.
Johansen, S. Estimation and hypothesis testing of cointegrated vectors in Gaussian VAR models. Econometrica 1991, 59:1551–1580.
Kalantzis, F. and Milonas,, NT. “Market integration and price dispersion in the European electricity market,” 2010 7th International Conference on the European Energy Market, Madrid, 23–25 June 2010, pp. 1–6. doi:10.1109/EEM.2010.5558751.
Bunn, D, Gianfreda, A. Integration and shock transmission across European electricity forward markets. Energy Econ 2010, 32:278–291.
Nitsch, R, Ockenfels, A, Roeller, L‐H. The electricity wholesale sector: market integration and competition. ESMT White Paper, 2010.
Panopoulou, E, Pantelidis, T. Club convergence in carbon dioxide emissions. Environ Resour Econ 2009, 44:47–70.
Ezcurra, R. Is there cross‐country convergence in carbon dioxide emissions? Energy Policy 2007a, 35:1363–1372.
Aldy, JE. Per capita carbon dioxide emissions: convergence or divergence? Environ Resour Econ 2006, 33:533–555.
Barassi, MR, Cole, MA, Elliott, JRR. The stochastic convergence of CO₂ emissions: a long memory approach. Environ Resour Econ 2011, 49:367–385.
Meng, M, Payne, JE, Lee, J. Convergence in per capita energy use among OECD countries. Energy Econ 2013, 36:536–545.
Mohammadi, H, Ram, R. Cross‐country convergence in energy and electricity consumption, 1971–2007. Energy Econ 2012, 34:1882–1887.
Duro, JA, Alcantara, V, Padilla, E. International inequality in energy intensity levels and the role of production composition and energy efficiency: an analysis of OECD countries. Ecol Econ 2010, 69:2468–2474.
Le Pen, Y, Sévi, B. On the non‐convergence of energy intensities: evidence from a pair‐wise econometric approach. Ecol Econ 2010, 69:641–650.
Liddle, B. Electricity intensity convergence in IEA/OECD countries: aggregate and sectoral analysis. Energy Policy 2009, 37:1470–1478.
Ezcurra, R. Distribution dynamics of energy intensities: a cross‐country analysis. Energy Policy 2007b, 35:5254–5259.
Markandya, A, Pedroso‐Galinato, S, Streimikiene, D. Energy intensity in transition economies: is there convergence towards the EU average? Energy Econ 2006, 28:121–145.
de Menezes, LM, Houllier, MA. Reassessing the integration of European electricity markets: a fractional cointegration analysis. Energy Econ 2016, 53:132–150.
Huisman, R, Kilic, M. A history of European electricity day‐ahead prices. Appl Econ 2013, 45:2683–2693.
Li, R, Joyeux, R, Ripple, RD. International natural gas market integration. Energy J 2014, 35:159–179.
SEIA. U.S. Solar Market Insight: Q2 2015, Q4 2015, and Q2 2016. In: Solar Energy Industries Association (SEIA)/Greentech Media (GTM) Research, Boston, MA, June 9, 2016. Available at http://www.seia.org. (Accessed August 22, 2016).
SEIA. Top 10 Solar States. In: Solar Energy Industries Association (SEIA)/Greentech Media (GTM) Research, 2016. Washington DC. December 2015. Available at: http://www.seia.org/sites/default/files/resources/Top%2010%20Solar%20States_2015_PRINT_7‐27‐16.pdf. (Accessed July 12, 2016).
Kiliccote, S, Olsen, D, Sohn, MD, Piette, MA. Characterization of demand response in the commercial, industrial, and residential sectors in the United States. WIREs Energy Environ 2016, 5:288–304. doi:10.1002/wene.176.
New York Public Service Commission. Reforming the Energy Vision. New York State Department of Public Service; 2015. Available at: http://www3.dps.ny.gov/W/PSCWeb.nsf/All/CC4F2EFA3A23551585257DEA007DCFE2?OpenDocument. Albany, New York. (Accessed April 6, 2016).
Cuddington, J, Wang, Z. Assessing the degree of spot market integration for US natural gas: evidence from daily price data. J Regul Econ 2006, 29:195–210.
Nyangon, J. The U.S. shale gas revolution and its implications for international energy policy. Green Monitor 2015, 3:184–190.
U.S. Energy Information Administration. Short‐Term Energy and Winter Fuels Outlook (STEO), 2014c. Available at: http://www.eia.gov/forecasts/aeo/pdf/0383(2014).pdf. (Accessed July 29, 2016).
BP. BP Statistical Review of World Energy 2014. London; BP, 2014. Available at: http://www.bp.com/content/dam/bp‐country/de_de/PDFs/brochures/BP‐statistical‐review‐of‐world‐energy‐2014‐full‐report.pdf. (Accessed November 20, 2015).
Fletcher, S. Goldilocks range` of prices. Oil Gas J 2009, 107:23–64. (Jun 15, 2009): ProQuest Pg. 64.
Walton, J. An Empirical Exploration of the Effects of Natural Gas Prices on Solar Energy Growth. Tacoma, WA: University of Puget Sound, 2013.
Lee, A, Zinaman, O, Logan, J. Opportunities for Synergy between Natural Gas and Renewable Energy in the Electric Power and Transportation Sectors. NREL/TP‐6A50‐56324. Joint Institute for Strategic Energy Analysis: Golden, CO; 2012. Available at: http://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy13osti/56324.pdf. (Accessed September 18, 2015).
Byrne, J, Taminiau, J. A review of sustainable energy utility and energy service utility concepts and applications: realizing ecological and social sustainability with a community utility. WIREs Energy Environ 2016, 5:136–154. doi:10.1002/wene.171.
Shavel, I, Fox‐Penner, P, Weiss, J, Hledik, R, Ruiz, P, Yang, Y, Carroll, R, Zahniser‐Word, J. Exploring Natural Gas and Renewables in ERCOT, Part III: The Role of Demand Response, Energy Efficiency, and Combined Heat and Power. Cambridge, MA: The Brattle Group, 2014.
Renou‐Maissant, P. Toward the integration of European natural gas markets: a time‐varying approach. Energy Policy 2012, 51:779–790.
U.S. Department of Energy. Solar Technologies Market Report. Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Washington DC, 2011. Available at: http://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy12osti/51847.pdf. (Accessed July 8, 2016).
U.S. Energy Information Administration. Today in energy: utility‐scale installations lead solar photovoltaic growth, 2012. Available at: http://www.eia.gov/forecasts/aeo/pdf/0383(2014).pdf. (Accessed July 14, 2016).
Mendelsohn, M, Lowder, T, Canavan, B. Utility‐scale concentrating solar power and photovoltaics projects: a technology and market overview. National Renewable Energy Laboratory, 2012. Available at: http://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy12osti/51137.pdf. (Accessed May 8, 2016).
Lacey, S. What do falling natural gas prices mean for renewables? 2012. Available at: http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2012/01/13/403833/what‐do‐falling‐natural‐gas‐prices‐mean‐for‐renewables/. (Accessed December 8, 2015).
Elbannan, M. The Capital Asset Pricing Model: an overview of the theory. Int J Econ Finance 2015, 7:216–228.
Markowitz, H. Portfolio selection. J Finance 1952, 7:77–99. doi:10.1111/j.1540‐6261.1952.tb01525.x.
Sharpe, W. Capital asset prices: a theory of market equilibrium under conditions of risk. J Finance 1964, 19:425–442. doi:10.1111/j.1540‐6261.1964.tb02865.x.
Lintner, J. The valuation of risk assets and the selection of risky investments in stock portfolios and capital budgets. Rev Econ Statistic 1965, 47:13–37. doi:10.2307/1924119.
Guesmi, K, Moisseron, J‐Y, Teulon, F. Integration versus segmentation in Middle East North Africa equity market: time variations and currency risk. J Int Financ Market Inst Money 2014, 28:204–212. doi:10.1016/j.intfin.2013.10.005.
Teulon, F, Guesmi, K, Mankai, S. Regional stock market integration in Singapore: a multivariate analysis. Econ Model 2014, 43:217–224.
Adam, K, Jappelli, T, Menichini, A, Padula, M, Pagano, M. Analyse, Compare, and Apply Alternative Indicators and Monitoring Methodologies to Measure the Evolution of Capital Market Integration in the European Union. Fisciano, Italy: Centre for Studies in Economics and Finance; 2002.
Fama, E, French, K. The Capital Asset Pricing Model: theory and evidence. J Econ Perspect 2004, 18:24–46. doi:10.1257/0895330042162430.
King, M, Cuc, M. Price convergence in North American natural gas spot markets. Energy J 1996, 17:17–39.
Zachmann, G. Convergence of electricity wholesale prices in Europe? A Kalman Filter Approach. Discussion Papers, DIW Berlin, September 1–27, 2005.
Phillips, PCB, Sul, D. Transition modeling and econometric convergence tests. Econometrica 2007, 2007:1771–1855.
Morvaj, B, Evins, R, Carmeliet, J. Optimization framework for distributed energy systems with integrated electrical grid constraints. Appl Energy 2016, 171:296–313.
Wu, J, Botterud, A, Mills, A, Zhou, Z, Hodge, BM, Heaney, M. Integrating solar PV (photovoltaics) in utility system operations: analytical framework and Arizona case study. Energy 2015, 85:1–9.
Hirth, L. The market value of variable renewables. Energy Econ 2013, 38:218–236. doi:10.1016/j.eneco.2013.02.004.
Hirth, L. The market value of solar power: is photovoltaics cost‐competitive? IET Renew Power Generat 2015, 9:37–45. doi:10.1049/iet‐rpg.2014.0101.
Pudjianto, D, Djapic, P, Dragovic, J, Strbac, G. Grid Integration Cost of PhotoVoltaic Power Generation. 2013. PVPARITY, Imperial College of London, September 2013. Available at: http://www.pvparity.eu/fileadmin/PVPARITY_docs/public/PV_PARITY_D44_Grid_integration_cost_of_PV_‐_Final_300913.pdf. (Accessed July 16, 2016).
Nicolosi, M. The economics of renewable electricity market integration. An empirical and model‐based analysis of regulatory frameworks and their impacts on the power market. PhD thesis, University of Cologne, 2012.
Byrne, J, Kurdgelashvili, L, Couey, J. PV Planner: A Design and Analysis Tool for Solar Electric Systems—Updated User Manual. Newark, DE: Center for Energy and Environmental Policy (CEEP); 2011. Available at: http://ceep.udel.edu/publications/ceep‐publications‐2011‐2012/. (Accessed July 16, 2016).
Gowrisankaran, G, Reynolds, SS, Samano,M. Intermittency and the value of renewable energy. NBER Working Paper 17086, 2011.
Mills, A. Assessment of the economic value of photovoltaic power at high penetration levels. Paper presented to UWIG Solar Integration Workshop, Maui, Hawaii, October 11, 2011. Available at: www.uwig.org/mwgintertal/de5fs23hu73ds/progress?id=XDyBuJov9m (Accessed October 12, 2016).
Lamont, A. Assessing the long‐term system value of intermittent electric generation technologies. Energy Econ 2008, 30:1208–1231.
Rahman, S, Bouzguenda, M. A model to determine the degree of penetration and energy cost of large scale utility interactive photovoltaic systems. IEEE Trans Energ Convers 1994, 9:224–230.
Rahman, S. Economic impact of integrating photovoltaics with conventional electric utility operation. IEEE Trans Energ Convers 1990, 5:422–428. doi:10.1109/60.105264.
Eryilmaz, D, Sergici, S. Integration of residential PV and its implications for current and future residential electricity demand in the United States. Electricity J 2016, 29:41–52.
Feldman, D, Barbose, GL, Margolis, R, James, T, Weaver, S, Darghouth, N, Fu, R, Davidson, C, Booth, S, Wiser, R. Photovoltaic system pricing trends—historical, recent, and near‐term projections 2014 edition. NREL/PR‐ 6A20‐62558, U.S. Department of Energy SunShot, 2014. Available at: http://www.nrel.gov/docs/57fy14osti/62558.pdf. (Accessed July 16, 2016).
Brown, S, Rowlands, I. Nodal pricing in Ontario, Canada: implications for solar PV electricity. Renew Energy 2009, 34:170–178.
Borenstein, S. The Market Value and Cost of Solar Photovoltaic Electricity Production. CSEM Working Paper 176, 2008.
Mills, A, Wiser, R. Changes in the economic value of variable generation at high penetration levels: a pilot case study of California. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory Paper LBNL‐5445E, 2012.
Mills, A, Wiser, R. Mitigation strategies for maintaining the economic value of variable generation at high penetration levels. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory Paper LBNL‐6590E, 2014.
Zhang, D, Broadstock, DC. Club Convergence in the Energy Intensity of China. Energy J 2016, 37:137–158.
Hirth, L, Ziegenhagen, I. Balancing power and variable renewables: three links. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2015, 50:1035–1051.
Hirth, L, Ueckerdt, F, Edenhofer, O. Integration costs revisited—an economic framework of wind and solar variability. Renew Energy 2015, 74:925–939. doi:10.1016/j.renene.2014.08.065.
Phillips, PCB, Sul, D. Economic transition and growth. J Appl Econ 2009, 2009:1153–1185.
Robinson, T. Have European gas prices converged? Energy Policy 2007, 35:2347–2351.
Wang, X, Kurdgelashvili, L, Byrne, J, Barnett, A. The value of module efficiency in lowering the levelized cost of energy of photovoltaic systems. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2011, 15:4248–4254.
Ondraczek, J, Komendantova, N, Patt, A. WACC the dog: the effect of financing costs on the levelized cost of solar PV power. Renew Energy 2015, 75:888–898.
Yegorov,, Yuri and Boudiaf, Ismael Alexander, US Shale Gas Revolution and World Gas Supply Shock (July 30, 2012). USAEE Working Paper No. 2142180. Vienna, Austria. Available at: SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2142180
U.S. Energy Information Administration. U.S. carbon dioxide emissions in 2009: a retrospective review. Department of Energy, 5 May, 2010.
Darghouth, N, Wiser, RH, Barbose, G. Customer economics of residential photovoltaic systems: sensitivities to changes in wholesale market design and rate structures. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2016, 54:1459–1469.

Further Reading

Hefley, EW, Yongsheng, W, eds. Economics of Unconventional Shale Gas Development: Case Studies and Impacts. New York: Springer, 2015. ISBN: 978‐3‐319‐11498‐9.

Access to this WIREs title is by subscription only.

Recommend to Your
Librarian Now!

The latest WIREs articles in your inbox

Sign Up for Article Alerts