How to cite this WIREs title:
WIREs Energy Environ.

Impact Factor: 2.922

A critical review of modern approaches for multidimensional energy poverty measurement

Overview

Setu Pelz, Shonali Pachauri, Sebastian Groh

Published Online: May 22 2018

DOI: 10.1002/wene.304

Full article on Wiley Online Library: HTML PDF

Can't access this content? Tell your librarian.

Recent efforts to measure energy poverty more comprehensively attempt to redress the shortcomings of binary metrics that remain in common use. However, significant challenges remain both with the construction of the new measurement frameworks and their application. The paper presents an analysis of recent multidimensional measurement approaches and applications to draw inferences on the implications of applying these for the measurement of energy access and in informing policies aimed at improving it. The assessment suggests that despite progress having been made in capturing the multidimensional nature of energy poverty, the new measures are currently too complex to operationalize at the global level and too prescriptive to gain acceptance in diverse national contexts. Further efforts are thus required to consolidate and simplify the new frameworks for global tracking purposes, and to adapt and modify these to specific country contexts to inform national policy and planning. A subset of key energy poverty dimensions and uniform set of indicators need to be shortlisted for the purposes of global comparisons, while specific national tracking efforts can apply dimensions and thresholds most suited to accurately capture energy poverty and its drivers in a given context. This article is categorized under: Energy Policy and Planning > Economics and Policy Energy and Development > Economics and Policy Energy Infrastructure > Economics and Policy

Multidimensional Energy Poverty Index dimensions and respective variables with cutoffs, including relative weights (in parenthesis) (Reprinted with permission from Nussbaumer et al., 2012 © Copyright 2012 Elsevier)

[ Normal View | Magnified View ]

Modifying the multitier framework for distinct global tracking and national planning purposes

[ Normal View | Magnified View ]

Tracking access at global and national levels (World Bank; International Energy Agency, )

[ Normal View | Magnified View ]

Comparison of the modified Multitier Framework for access to cooking energy services in India (Reprinted with permission from Jain et al., 2016 © 2016 Copyright Practical Action Publishing)

[ Normal View | Magnified View ]

Excerpt of the Multitier Framework matrix for measuring indoor air quality: Rough and conservative approach. (Bhatia & Angelou, )

[ Normal View | Magnified View ]

Multitier Framework matrix for access to household electricity services (Bhatia & Angelou, )

[ Normal View | Magnified View ]

References

AGECC. (2010). Energy for a sustainable future, the Secretary‐General`s Advisory Group on Energy and Climate Change. New York, NY: United Nations. Available at: http://www.unido.org/fileadmin/user_media/Services/Energy_and_Climate_Change/EPP/Publications/AGECC_Report.pdf.
Aklin,, M., Cheng,, C. Y., Urpelainen,, J., Ganesan,, K., & Jain,, A. (2016). Factors affecting household satisfaction with electricity supply in rural India. Nature Energy, 1(11), 1–6.
Alem,, Y., Hassen,, S., & Köhlin,, G. (2017). Decision‐making within the household: The role of differences in preference and autonomy, Working paper in Economics No. 724, School of Business, Economics and Law, University of Gothenburg, Sweden. ISSN 1403‐2465.
Alkire,, S. (2002). Dimensions of human development. World Development, 30(2), 181–205.
Alkire,, S., & Santos,, M. E. (2014). Measuring acute poverty in the developing world: Robustness and scope of the Multidimensional Poverty Index. World Development, 59, 251–274.
Baquié,, S., & Urpelainen,, J. (2017). Access to modern fuels and satisfaction with cooking arrangements: Survey evidence from rural India. Energy for Sustainable Development, 38, 34–47.
Barnes,, D. F., Khandker,, S. R., & Samad,, H. A. (2011). Energy poverty in rural Bangladesh. Energy Policy, 39(2), 894–904.
Bazilian,, M., Nussbaumer,, P., Cabraal,, A., Centurelli,, R., Detchon,, R., Gielen,, D., … Ziegler,, F. (2010). Measuring Energy Access: Supporting a Global Target. New York, NY.
Bazilian,, M., & Pielke,, R., Jr. (2013). Making energy access meaningful. Issues in Science and Technology, 29, 74–78.
Bensch,, G. (2013). Inside the metrics—An empirical comparison of energy poverty indices for sub‐Saharan countries. Ruhr Economic Papers No. 464. Ruhr‐Universität Bochum, Technische Universität Dortmund, Universität Duisburg‐Essen, Rheinisch‐Westfälisches Institut für Wirtschaftsforschung (RWI), Germany.
Best,, S. (2013). Shaping a global goal on energy access that leaves no one behind. London, England.
Bhanot,, J., & Jha,, V. (2012). Moving towards tangible decision‐making tools for policy makers: Measuring and monitoring energy access provision. Energy Policy, 47, 64–70.
Bhatia,, M. (2013). Defining and measuring access to energy. SREP Pilot Country Meeting, May 28‐30, 2013, Maldives. World Bank.
Bhatia,, M. & Angelou,, N. (2014) Capturing the multi‐dimensionality of energy access. Live wire knowledge note series; no. 2014/16. Washington, DC : World Bank Group. http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/937711468320944879/Capturing-the-multi-dimensionality-of-energy-access
Bhatia,, M. & Angelou,, N. (2015) Beyond Connections: Energy Access Redefined. Energy Sector Management Assistance Program (ESMAP). Washington, D.C. : World Bank Group. http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/650971468180259602/Beyond-connections-energy-access-redefined-technical-report
Bouzarovski,, S., & Petrova,, S. (2015). A global perspective on domestic energy deprivation: Overcoming the energy poverty–fuel poverty binary. Energy Research %26 Social Science, 10, 31–40.
Brand‐Correa,, L. I., & Steinberger,, J. K. (2017). A framework for decoupling human need satisfaction from energy use. Ecological Economics, 141, 43–52.
Broto,, V. C., Stevens,, L., Ackom,, E., Tomei,, J., Parikh,, P., Bisaga,, I., … Mulugetta,, Y. (2017). A research agenda for a people‐centred approach to energy access in the urbanizing global south. Nature Energy, 2(10), 776–779.
Culver,, L. (2017) Energy poverty: What you measure matters. In Pre‐symposium White Paper for ‐ Reducing Energy Poverty with Natural Gas: Changing Political, Business, and Technology Paradigms (pp. 1–25). Stanford, CA: Natural Gas Initiative, Stanford University.
Dagnachew,, A. G., Lucas,, P. L., Hof,, A. F., Gernaat,, D. E. H. J., de Boer,, H. S., & van Vuuren,, D. P. (2017). The role of decentralized systems in providing universal electricity access in Sub‐Saharan Africa—A model‐based approach. Energy, 139, 184–195.
Day,, R., Walker,, G., & Simcock,, N. (2016). Conceptualising energy use and energy poverty using a capabilities framework. Energy Policy, 93, 255–264.
Goldemberg,, J., Johansson,, T. B., Reddy,, A. K. N., & Williams,, R. H. (1985). Basic needs and much more with one kilowatt per capita. Ambio, 14, 190–200.
Graber,, S., Narayanan,, T., Alfaro,, J. F., & Palit,, D. (2018). Solar microgrids in rural India: Consumers’ willingness to pay for attributes of electricity. Energy for Sustainable Development, 42(In press), 32–43.
Groh,, S. (2014). The role of energy in development processes‐The energy poverty penalty: Case study of Arequipa (Peru). Energy for Sustainable Development, 18, 83–99.
Groh,, S., Pachauri,, S., & Narasimha,, R. (2016). What are we measuring? An empirical analysis of household electricity access metrics in rural Bangladesh. Energy for Sustainable Development, 30, 21–31.
World Bank; International Energy Agency. (2015). Sustainable Energy for All 2015 : Progress Toward Sustainable Energy. Washington, DC: World Bank. © World Bank; International Energy Agency. https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/22148 License: CC BY 3.0 IGO.
International Energy Agency (IEA) and the World Bank. (2017). “Sustainable Energy for All 2017–Progress toward Sustainable Energy.” World Bank, Washington, DC. License: Creative Commons Attribution CC BY 3.0 IGO
Jain,, A., Ray,, S., Ganesan,, K., Aklin,, M., Cheng,, C., & Urpelainen,, J. (2015). Access to clean cooking energy and electricity. New Delhi, India: ACEESS—Survey of States.
Jain,, A., Urpelainen,, J. and Stevens,, L. (2016) Measuring energy access in India: Insights from applying a multi‐tier framework in cooking energy and household electricity.
Jannuzzi,, G. D. M., & Goldemberg,, J. (2012). Has the situation of the ’have‐nots’ improved? Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Energy and Environment, 1, 41–50.
Kemmler,, A., & Spreng,, D. (2007). Energy indicators for tracking sustainability in developing countries. Energy Policy, 35, 2466–2480.
Kowsari,, R., & Zerriffi,, H. (2011). Three dimensional energy profile: A conceptual framework for assessing household energy use. Energy Policy, 39, 7505–7517.
Lam,, N. L., Upadhyay,, B., Maharjan,, S., Jagoe,, K., Weyant,, C. L., Thompson,, R., … Bond,, T. C. (2017). Seasonal fuel consumption, stoves, and end‐uses in rural households of the far‐western development region of Nepal. Environmental Research Letters, 12(12).
Lucas,, K., Mattioli,, G., Verlinghieri,, E., & Guzman,, A. (2016). Transport poverty and its adverse social consequences. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers ‐ Transport, 169, 353–365.
Lucon,, O., Coelho,, S. T., & Goldemberg,, J. (2004). LPG in Brazil: lessons and challenges. Energy for Sustainable Development, 8, 82–90.
McCollum,, D. L., Echeverri,, L. G., Busch,, S., Pachauri,, S., Parkinson,, S., Rogelj,, J., … Riahi,, K. (2018). Connecting the sustainable development goals by their energy inter‐linkages. Environmental Research Letters, 13(3), 33006.
Mentis,, D., Howells,, M., Rogner,, H., Korkovelos,, A., Arderne,, C., Zepeda,, E., … Scholtz,, E. (2017). Lighting the World: the first application of an open source, spatial electrification tool (OnSSET) on Sub‐Saharan Africa. Environmental Research Letters, 12(8), 85003.
Mentis,, D., Welsch,, M., Fuso Nerini,, F., Broad,, O., Howells,, M., Bazilian,, M., & Rogner,, H. (2015). A GIS‐based approach for electrification planning—A case study on Nigeria. Energy for Sustainable Development, 29, 142–150.
Modi,, V., McDade,, S., Lallement,, D., & Saghir,, J. (2006). Energy and the millennium development goals. New York: Energy Sector Management Assistance Programme, United Nations Development Programme, UN Millennium Project, and World Bank.
Moksnes,, N., Korkovelos,, A., Mentis,, D., & Howells,, M. (2017). Electrification pathways for Kenya—Linking spatial electrification analysis and medium to long term energy planning. Environmental Research Letters.
Nerini,, F. F., Broad,, O., Mentis,, D., Welsch,, M., Bazilian,, M., & Howells,, M. (2016). A cost comparison of technology approaches for improving access to electricity services. Energy, 95, 255–265.
Nerini,, F. F., Dargaville,, R., Howells,, M., & Bazilian,, M. (2015). Estimating the cost of energy access: The case of the village of Suro Craic in Timor Leste. Energy, 79(C, 385–397.
Nerini,, F. F., Ray,, C., & Boulkaid,, Y. (2017). The cost of cooking a meal. the case of Nyeri County, Kenya. Environmental Research Letters, 12(6).
Nussbaumer,, P., Bazilian,, M., & Modi,, V. (2012). Measuring energy poverty: Focusing on what matters. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 16, 231–243.
Nussbaumer,, P., Nerini,, F. F., Onyeji,, I., & Howells,, M. (2013). Global insights based on the Multidimensional Energy Poverty Index (MEPI). Sustainability, 5, 2060–2076.
O`Sullivan,, K., & Barnes,, D. F. (2007). Energy policies and multitopic household surveys : Guidelines for questionnaire design in living standards measurement studies (No. 90). World Bank Working Paper. Washington, DC : World Bank. © World Bank. https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/6615 License: CC BY 3.0 IGO.
Ogwumike,, F. O., & Ozughalu,, U. M. (2016). Analysis of energy poverty and its implications for sustainable development in Nigeria. Environment and Development Economics, 21(3), 273–290.
Olang,, T. A., Esteban,, M., & Gasparatos,, A. (2018). Lighting and cooking fuel choices of households in Kisumu City, Kenya: A multidimensional energy poverty perspective. Energy for Sustainable Development, 42, 1–13.
Pachauri,, S. (2011). Reaching an international consensus on defining modern energy access. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, 3(4), 235–240.
Pachauri,, S., & Brew‐Hammond,, A. (2012). Chapter 19: Energy access for development. In Global energy assessment (pp. 1401–1458). Cambridge, England; New York, NY; Laxenburg, Austria: Cambridge University Press; International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis.
Pachauri,, S., Mueller,, A., Kemmler,, A., & Spreng,, D. (2004). On measuring energy poverty in Indian households. World Development, 32, 2083–2104.
Pachauri,, S., Scott,, A., Scott,, L., & Shepherd,, A. (2013). Energy for all: Harnessing the power of energy access for chronic poverty reduction (Policy Guide No. 3). London, UK: Chronic Poverty Advisory Network.
Pachauri,, S., & Spreng,, D. (2004). Energy use and energy access in relation to poverty. Economic and Political Weekly, 271–278.
Pachauri,, S., & Spreng,, D. (2011). Measuring and monitoring energy poverty. Energy Policy, 39, 7497–7504.
Practical Action. (2010). Poor people`s energy outlook 2010. Rugby, England: Author.
Practical Action. (2012). Poor people`s energy outlook 2012: Energy for earning a living. Rugby, England: Author.
Practical Action. (2013). Poor people`s energy outlook 2013: Energy for community services. Rugby, England: Author.
Practical Action. (2014). Poor people`s energy outlook 2014: Key messages on energy for poverty alleviation. Rugby, England: Author.
Practical Action. (2016). Poor people`s energy outlook 2016: National energy access planning from the bottom up. Rugby, England: Author.
Practical Action. (2017). Poor people`s energy outlook 2017: Financing national energy access: a bottom‐up approach. Rugby, England: Author.
Rao,, N., & Pachauri,, S. (2017). Energy access and living standards: Some observations on recent trends. Environmental Research Letters, 12.
Rao,, N. D., & Min,, J. (2017). Decent living standards: Material prerequisites for human wellbeing. Social Indicators Research, 1–20.
Rasel,, A. R. (2017) PDB for bringing battery‐run vehicles under tariff regulations. Retrieved from www.dhakatribune.com/bangladesh/power-energy/2017/09/27/pdb-bringing-battery-run-vehicles-tariff-regulations/
Rawls,, J. (1971). A theory of justice. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
Reddy,, A. K. (2000). chapter 2: energy and social issues. In World energy assessment (pp. 39–58). UNDP.
Reddy,, B. S. (2015). Access to modern energy services: An economic and policy framework. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 47, 198–212.
Riva,, F., Ahlborg,, H., Hartvigsson,, E., Pachauri,, S., & Colombo,, E. (2018). Electricity access and rural development: Review of complex socio‐economic dynamics and casual diagrams for more appropriate energy modelling. Energy for Sustainable Development, 43, 203–223.
Sadath,, A. C., & Acharya,, R. H. (2017). Assessing the extent and intensity of energy poverty using Multidimensional Energy Poverty Index: Empirical evidence from households in India. Energy Policy, 102, 540–548.
Sen,, A. (1992). Inequality reexamined. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Sher,, F., Abbas,, A., & Awan,, R. U. (2014). An investigation of multidimensional energy poverty in Pakistan: A province level analysis. International Journal of Energy Economics and Policy, 4(1), 65–75.
Sovacool,, B. K., Cooper,, C., Bazilian,, M., Johnson,, K., Zoppo,, D., Clarke,, S., … Raza,, H. A. (2012). What moves and works: Broadening the consideration of energy poverty. Energy Policy, 42, 715–719.
Tait,, L. (2017). Towards a multidimensional framework for measuring household energy access: Application to South Africa. Energy for Sustainable Development, 38, 1–9.
Thomson,, H., Bouzarovski,, S., & Snell,, C. (2017). Rethinking the measurement of energy poverty in Europe: A critical analysis of indicators and data. Indoor and Built Environment, 26, 879–901.
Trace,, S. (2015). Chapter 11: Measuring access for different needs. In L. Gurswamy, (Ed.), International energy and poverty: The emerging contours (pp. 160–178). Routledge.
UN Energy. (2005). the energy challenge for achieving the Millennium development goals.
UN Women. (2018). Turning promises into action: Gender equality in the 2030 agenda for sustainable development.
UNDP. (2005). Achieving the Millennium development goals: The Role of energy services (Technical Report). New York, NY: Author.
UNDP and WHO. (2009) The energy access situation in developing countries: A review focusing on the least developed countries and sub‐Saharan Africa.
Urpelainen,, J. (2016). Energy poverty and perceptions of solar power in marginalized communities: Survey evidence from Uttar Pradesh, India. Renewable Energy, 85, 534–539.
WHO. (2014). WHO indoor air quality guidelines: Household fuel combustion. (Technical Report). Geneva, Switzerland: Author.
Winkler,, H., Simões,, A. F., la Rovere,, E. L., Alam,, M., Rahman,, A., & Mwakasonda,, S. (2011). Access and affordability of electricity in developing countries. World Development, 39(6), 1037–1050.
World Bank; International Energy Agency. (2014). Sustainable energy for all 2013‐2014: Global tracking framework report. (Technical Report No. 77889). Washington, DC: World Bank.

Further Reading

Bhatia, M, Angelou, N. Beyond connections: Energy access redefined; 2015.
Culver,, L. (2017). Energy poverty: What you measure matters. In Pre‐symposium white paper for ‐ Reducing energy poverty with natural gas: Changing political, business, and technology paradigms (pp. 1–25). Stanford, CA: Natural Gas Initiative, Stanford University.
Najam,, A., & Cleveland,, C. J. (2003). Energy and sustainable development at global environmental summits: An evolving agenda. Environment, Development and Sustainability, 5, 117–138.
UN. (1992) The Rio declaration on environment %26 development (Technical Report).
UN. (2015). Transforming our world: The 2030 agenda for sustainable development (Technical Report).

Access to this WIREs title is by subscription only.

Recommend to Your
Librarian Now!

The latest WIREs articles in your inbox

Sign Up for Article Alerts