A review of international practices for energy efficiency and carbon emissions reduction and lessons learned for China

Advanced Review

Xu Liu, Bo Shen, Lynn Price, Ali Hasanbeigi, Hongyou Lu, Cong Yu, Guanyun Fu

Published Online: Mar 26 2019

DOI: 10.1002/wene.342

Full article on Wiley Online Library: HTML PDF

Can't access this content? Tell your librarian.

China's industrial sector dominates the country's total energy consumption, and improving energy efficiency in that sector is crucial to help China reach its energy and carbon dioxide emissions reduction goals. There are many energy efficiency policies in China, but the motivation and willingness of enterprises to improve energy efficiency has weakened. This article first identifies barriers that enterprises face to be self‐motivated to implement energy efficiency measures and then categorizes these barriers into four categories: awareness, information, technical capacity, and financial availability. It then reviews international policies and programs to improve energy efficiency, and evaluates how these policies have helped to address the barriers identified. We found that policies and programs in energy efficiency and carbon reduction need to go hand in hand to incentivize companies, and that those policies and programs send clearer signals and help change enterprises' decisions when they are persistent but dynamic. Our specific policy recommendations to China fall under three key categories: identification of energy efficiency potential, workforce development, and market channels for energy efficiency financing. This article is categorized under: Energy and Climate > Economics and Policy Energy Efficiency > Economics and Policy Energy Efficiency > Climate and Environment

China's energy‐related carbon dioxide emissions and its comparison with the United States, 1980–2015

[ Normal View | Magnified View ]

References

Aaltonen,, P. (2011). Systems and their applicability to Finland. Report to Ympäristöpooli at Finnish Energy Industries.
ABB. (2013). Energy efficiency country report – Poland, February.
Abdelaziz,, E., Saidur,, R., & Mekhilef,, S. (2011). A review on energy saving strategies in industrial sector. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 15(1), 150–168.
Aflaki,, S., Kleindorfer,, R., Polvorinos,, M., & Sáenz,, V. (2013). Finding and implementing energy efficiency projects in industrial facilities. Production and Operations Management, 22(3), 503–517.
Altmann,, M., Zerhusen,, J., Maio,, P., Lanoix,, J., Trucco,, P., Egenhofer,, C., … Theiss,, J. (2013). Energy efficiency and the ETS. European Parliament.
Barker,, T., Ekins,, P., & Foxon,, T. (2007). Macroeconomic effects of efficiency policies for energy‐intensive industries: The case of the UK climate change agreements, 2000–2010. Energy Economics, 29, 760–778.
Belden,, A., Clemmer,, S., & Wright,, K. (2015). Financing clean energy: Cost‐effective tools for state compliance with the clean power plan. Union of Concerned Scientists.
Benchmarking Commission. (2004). Annual report on the year 2004 – Evaluation report 2002–2004.
Bertoldi,, P. (1999). The use of long‐term agreements to improve energy efficiency in the industrial sector: Overview of the European experiences and proposal for a common framework. Proceedings of the 1999 American Council for an energy‐efficient economy summer study on energy efficiency in industry. Washington, DC: ACEEE.
Bertoldi,, P. (2011). Assessment and experience of white certificate schemes in the European union. IEA.
Bertoldi,, P., Rezessy,, S., & Vine,, E. (2006). Energy service companies in European countries: Current status and a strategy to foster their development. Energy Policy, 34(14), 1818–1832.
Bhandari,, D., & Shrimali,, G. (2018). The perform, achieve and trade scheme in India: An effectiveness analysis. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 81, 1286–1295.
Brogi,, A., & D`Adamo,, C. (2007). Impact of end‐use energy efficiency on the distribution network. CIRED 19th International Conference on Electricity Distribution, Vienna, 21–24 May 2007.
Brown,, M. (2001). Market failures and barriers as a basis for clean energy policies. Energy Policy, 29(14), 1197–1207.
Brown,, M., Hanafi,, A., & Petsonk,, A. (2012). The EU emissions trading system: Results and lessons learned. Washington, DC: Environmental Defense Fund.
Bureau of Energy Efficiency. Government of India. (forthcoming). PAT cycle. Retrieved from https://beeindia.gov.in/content/pat-cycle
Cagno,, E., Trianni,, A., Abeelen,, C., Worrell,, E., & Miggiano,, F. (2015). Barriers and drivers for energy efficiency: Different perspectives from an exploratory study in The Netherlands. Energy Conversion and Management, 102, 26–38.
California Air Resources Board (CARB). (2011). Overview of ARB Emissions Trading Program. Retrieved from http://www.arb.ca.gov/newsrel/2011/cap_trade_overview.pdf
California Air Resources Board (CARB). (2014). 2020 Business‐as‐Usual (BAU) emissions projection: 2014 edition.
California Air Resources Board (CARB). (2018). Annual report to the legislature on California climate investments using cap‐and‐trade auction proceeds.
Carbon Trust. (n.d.). Interest free energy efficiency loans in Wales. Retrieved from http://www.carbontrust.com/client-services/technology/implementation-and-finance/interest-free-loans-wales/
Chidiak,, M. (1999). Voluntary agreements for energy efficiency in five EU countries. In Energy efficiency and CO₂ reduction: The dimensions of social change: 1999 European council for an energy‐efficient economy summer study, May 31–June 4, Mandelieu, France 1999.
China Dialogue. (2017). Five things to know about China`s national carbon market. Retrieved from https://www.chinadialogue.net/blog/10303-Five-things-to-know-about-China-s-national-carbon-market/en
Climate and Development Knowledge Network. (2013, January). Creating market support for energy efficiency: India`s Perform achieve and trade scheme.
Confederation of British Industry (CBI). (2013). Shining a light uncovering the business energy efficiency opportunity.
Confederation of British Industry (CBI). (2015). The future of the energy company obligation.
Cornelis,, E. (2014). Lessons learnt from two long‐term agreements on energy‐efficiency in industry in Flanders, Belgium. ECEEE Industrial Summer Study Proceedings.
Current Affairs Reports. (2010). Gap of energy intensity between China and developed countries (in Chinese).
De Beer,, J., Kerssemeeckers,, M., Aalbers,, R., Vollebergh,, H., Ossokina,, J., de Groot,, H., … Blok,, K. (2000). Effectiveness energy subsidies: A study of the effectiveness of several subsidy and fiscal instruments in the period 1988–1999. Utrecht, The Netherlands: Ecofys.
DeCanio,, S. (1993). Barriers within firms to energy‐efficient investments. Energy Policy, 21(9), 906–914.
Department of Environment, Food, and Rural Affairs (DEFRA). (2006). Climate change: The UKProgramme 2006. London, England: DEFRA.
Di Santo,, D., Forni,, D., Venturini,, V., & Biele,, E. (2011). The white certificate scheme: The Italian experience and proposals for improvement. European Council for an Energy Efficient Economy (ECEEE) Summer Study.
Ekins,, P., & Etheridge,, B. (2006). The environmental and economic impacts of the UK climate change agreements. Energy Policy, 34, 2071–2086.
Elliott,, N. (2007). Energy investment decisions in the industrial sector. American Council for an Energy‐Efficient Economy (ACEEE).
Energy Charter Secretariat. (2010). Market trading mechanisms for delivering energy efficiency. Brussels, Belgium.
European Commission. (2011). Commission Decision of 27 April 2011 determining transitional Union‐wide rules for harmonised free allocation of emission allowances pursuant to Article 10a of Directive 2003/87/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council. Retrieved from http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:32011D0278
European Commission. (forthcoming). The EU emissions trading system (EU ETS). Retrieved from http://ec.europa.eu/clima/policies/ets/index_en.htm
Friedman,, B., Bird,, L., & Barbose,, G. (2009). Energy savings certificate markets: Opportunities and implementation barriers. In ASME 2009 3rd international conference on energy sustainability collocated with the heat transfer and InterPACK09 conferences 2009: 1–11. American Society of Mechanical Engineers.
Geller,, H., Harrington,, P., Rosenfeld,, A., Tanishima,, S., & Unander,, F. (2006). Polices for increasing energy efficiency: Thirty years of experience in OECD countries. Energy Policy, 34(5), 556–573.
Giraudet,, G., Bodineau,, L., & Finon,, D. (2012). The costs and benefits of white certificates schemes. Energy Efficiency, 5(2), 179–199.
Goldberg,, A., Taylor,, R., & Hedman,, B. (2014). Industrial energy efficiency: Designing effective state programs for the industrial sector. Institute for Industrial Productivity.
Goldman,, C., Hopper,, N., & Osborn,, J. (2005). Review of US ESCO industry market trends: An empirical analysis of project data. Energy Policy, 33(3), 387–405.
Golove,, W., & Eto,, J. (1996). Market barriers to energy efficiency: A critical reappraisal of the rationale for public policies to promote energy efficiency (Report LBNL‐38059). Berkeley CA: Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.
Green Investment Bank. (2015). Annual report and accounts 2014–15.
Grüning,, C., Menzel,, C., Panofen,, T., & Shuford, L. (2012). National climate finance institutions support program, case study: The Thai energy efficiency revolving fund. UNEP and Frankfurt School of Finance & Management.
Hansen,, K., & Larsen,, A. (1999). Voluntary agreements in industry: A comparative description of the process and a normative analysis. Proceedings of the 1999 American council for an energy‐efficient economy summer study on energy efficiency in industry. Washington, DC: ACEEE.
Harrison,, D., & Radov,, D. (2002). Evaluation of alternative initial allocation mechanisms in a European union greenhouse gas emissions allowance trading scheme. National Economic Research Associates Report to the European Commission`s DG Environment.
HM Revenue %26 Customs with HM Treasury %26 Defra. (2008). Evaluation of enhanced capital allowance (ECA) for energy saving technologies.
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. (2003). Revised 1996 IPCC guidelines for national greenhouse gas inventories: Reference manual.
International Emissions Trading Association (IETA). (2013). The world`s carbon markets: A case study guide to emissions trading ‐ United Kingdom.
International Emissions Trading Association. (2015). The World`s carbon markets: A case study guide to emissions trading ‐ India.
International Energy Agency. (2011). Joint public‐private approaches for energy efficiency finance policies to scale‐up private sector investment.
International Energy Agency. (forthcoming). Energy efficiency policies and measures database. Retrieved from http://www.iea.org/policiesandmeasures/energyefficiency/
Investopedia. (forthcoming). Free rider problem. Retrieved from http://www.investopedia.com/terms/f/free_rider_problem.asp
ISWte for Industrial Productivity. (forthcoming). Industrial efficiency policy database, Netherland, Long‐Term Agreements on Energy Efficiency. Retrieved from http://iepd.iipnetwork.org/policy/long-term-agreements-energy-efficiency
Johansson,, M. T., & Thollander,, P. (2018). A review of barriers to and driving forces for improved energy efficiency in Swedish industry–recommendations for successful in‐house energy management. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 82, 618–628.
Kiung,, K., & Morehouse,, E. (2015). Carbon market California: A comprehensive analysis of the Golden State`s cap‐and‐trade program, Year two: 2014. Environmental Defense Fund (EDF).
Labanca,, N. (2008). White certificates: Concept and market experiences. Retrieved from http://www.ewc.polimi.it/documents/EWC_brochure.pdf
Laing,, T., Sato,, M., Grubb,, M., & Comberti,, C. (2013). Assessing the effectiveness of the EU emissions trading system. Centre for Climate Change Economics and Policy.
Lo,, K. (2014). A critical review of China`s rapidly developing renewable energy and energy efficiency policies. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 29, 508–516.
Mazurek,, J., & Lehman,, B. (1999). Monitoring and verification of long‐term voluntary approaches in the industrial sector: An initial survey. Proceedings of the 1999 American Council for an Energy‐Efficient Economy Summer Study on energy efficiency in industry. Washington, DC: ACEEE.
McKane,, A. (2013). Assessing the costs and benefits of the superior energy performance program. American Council for an Energy‐Efficient Economy Summer Study on energy efficiency in industry. Niagra Falls, NY.
Ministry of Power, Government of India. (2017). Achievements under Perform, Achieve and Trade (PAT). Retrieved from https://www.beeindia.gov.in/sites/default/files/Booklet_Achievements%20under%20PAT_May%202017.pdf
National Bureau of Statistics. (2016). China energy statistical yearbook 2015. Beijing, China: China Statistics Press.
National Development and Reform Commission. (2011). Notice on top‐10,000 enterprises energy efficiency and low carbon implementation plan (in Chinese).
National Development and Reform Commission. (2015). Evaluation of top‐10,000 enterprises for the year of 2014 (in Chinese).
National Development and Reform Commission. (2016). Notice on key tasks of launching national carbon trading system (in Chinese). Retrieved from http://www.ndrc.gov.cn/zcfb/zcfbtz/201601/t20160122_772123.html
National Development and Reform Commission. (2017). Plan for National Carbon Trading System Establishment (Power Generation Sector) (in Chinese). Retrieved from http://www.ndrc.gov.cn/gzdt/201712/W020171220577386656660.pdf
Newman,, J. (1998). Evaluation of energy‐related voluntary agreements, in Martin et al., (eds.) Industrial energy efficiency policies: Understanding success and failure: Proceedings of a workshop organized by the international network for energy demand analysis in the industrial sector. Utrecht, The Netherlands. LBNL‐42368.
Paton,, B. (2002). Voluntary environmental initiatives and sustainable industry. In P. ten Brink, (Ed.), Voluntary environmental agreements: Process, practice and future use. Sheffield, England: Greenleaf.
Pender, M. (2008). UK climate change programme: Business and public sector economic instruments, presentation at the UN‐energy expert group meeting on advancing industrial energy efficiency in the Post‐2012 framework. Washington, DC. Retrieved from https://www.unido.org/fileadmin/user_media/Services/Energy_and_Climate_Change/EPU/Pender.pdf
Price,, L. (2005). Voluntary agreements for energy efficiency or GHG emissions reduction in industry: An assessment of programs around the world. ACEEE Summer Study on Energy Efficiency in Industry.
Price,, L., Blok,, K., Nuijen,, W., & Pender,, M. (2005). Setting voluntary agreement targets, presentation at the workshop on energy efficiency agreements, Beijing.
Price,, L., Galitsky,, C., Sinton,, J., Worrell,, E., & Graus,, W. (2005). Tax and fiscal policies for promotion of industrial energy efficiency: A survey of international experience. LBNL report.
Price,, L., & Lu,, H. (2011). Industrial energy auditing and assessments: A survey of programs around the world. In Proceedings of the European Council for an Energy‐Efficient Economy`s 2011 summer study on energy efficiency.
Price,, L., Worrell,, E., Sinton,, J., & Yun,, J. (2003). Voluntary agreements for increasing energy‐efficiency in industry: Case study of a pilot project with the steel industry in Shandong Province, China. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.
Reinaud,, J., & Goldberg,, A. (2011). The boardroom perspective: How does energy efficiency policy influence decision making in industry? (IEA‐IIP Information paper). IEA/OECD, Paris.
Rezessy,, S., & Bertoldi,, P. (2011). Voluntary agreements in the field of energy efficiency and emission reduction: Review and analysis of experiences in the European Union. Energy Policy, 39(11), 7121–7129.
Ryan,, L., Jessula,, E., & Rozite,, V. (2012). The European experience with tax relief for energy efficient equipment in industry – All bad or just second best? ECEEE 2012 summer study on energy efficiency in industry.
Sarkar,, A., & Singh,, J. (2010). Financing energy efficiency in developing countries—Lessons learned and remaining challenges. Energy Policy, 38(10), 5560–5571.
Schleich,, J., Rogge,, K., & Betz,, R. (2009). Incentives for energy efficiency in the EU emissions trading scheme. Energy Efficiency, 2(1), 37–67.
Smith,, S., & Swierzbinski,, J. (2007). Assessing the performance of the UK emissions trading scheme. Environmental and Resource Economics, 37(1), 131–158.
Steuwer,, D. (2012). Energy efficiency governance: The case of white certificate instruments for energy efficiency in Europe. Berlin, Germany: Springer Science %26 Business Media.
Streitferdt,, V., & Chirarattananon,, S. (2015). Energy efficiency finance support in Thailand: Lessons learned from the energy efficiency revolving fund. Journal of Sustainable Energy %26 Environment, 6, 13–16.
Trianni,, A., Cagno,, E., & Farné,, S. (2016). Barriers, drivers and decision‐making process for industrial energy efficiency: A broad study among manufacturing small and medium‐sized enterprises. Applied Energy, 162, 1537–1551.
U.S. Department of Energy. (2011). Energy savings performance contracting: The investment grade audit.
U.S. Department of Energy. (2015a). Federal ESPC process Phase 3: Project development.
U.S. Department of Energy (DOE). (2015b). IAC quarterly updates.
U.S. Department of Energy (DOE). (forthcoming). Section 1703 loan program. Retrieved from http://energy.gov/lpo/services/section-1703-loan-program
U.S. Energy Information Administration. (2016). U.S. energy‐related carbon dioxide emissions, 2015. Washington, DC: U.S. EIA.
UK Steel. (2007). UKSteel annual review 2007. London, England: EEF.
United States Agency for International Development. (2009). Innovative approaches to financing energy efficiency in Asia.
Vine,, E. (2005). An international survey of the energy service company (ESCO) industry. Energy Policy, 33(5), 691–704.
World Bank. (2015). India ‐ Partial Risk Sharing Facility for Energy Efficiency (PRSF) project. Washington, DC: World Bank Group.
World Bank. (n.d.). Putting a price on carbon with an ETS. Retrieved from http://www.worldbank.org/content/dam/Worldbank/document/Climate/background-note_ets.pdfhttp://www.worldbank.org/content/dam/Worldbank/document/Climate/background-note_ets.pdf
Yang,, M., Hu,, Z., & Yuan,, J. (2016). The recent history and successes of China`s energy efficiency policy. WIREs Energy and Environment, 5(6), 715–730.
Yu,, C., & Fu,, G. (2017). Market‐oriented energy efficiency mechanism design for key energy‐intensive enterprises (in Chinese). Beijing, China: China Science and Technology Press.
Yuan,, J., Kang,, J., Yu,, C., & Hu,, Z. (2011). Energy conservation and emissions reduction in China—Progress and prospective. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 15(9), 4334–4347.
Zhou,, N., Levine,, M., & Price,, L. (2010). Overview of current energy‐efficiency policies in China. Energy Policy, 38(11), 6439–6452.
Zuckerman,, J., Laughlin,, K., Abramskiehn,, D., & Wang,, X. (2014). Cap and trade in practice: Barriers and opportunities for industrial emissions reductions in California (CPI Working Paper).

Access to this WIREs title is by subscription only.

Recommend to Your
Librarian Now!

A review of international practices for energy efficiency and carbon emissions reduction and lessons learned for China

Browse by Topic

Access to this WIREs title is by subscription only.

The latest WIREs articles in your inbox